The Original Pirates of the Caribbean Trilogy Wasted Its Best Villain

In the third Pirates of the Caribbean movie, Tia Dalma turned out to be an incredibly powerful goddess, Calypso, but the trilogy still squandered her.

the original Pirates of the Caribbean The trilogy had a unique villain in Tia Dalma/Calypso, but the franchise spoiled the character by trapping her in a boring side story. the Pirates of the Caribbean the movies haven’t, it’s fair to say, made the most of their supporting stars. Despite an impressive cast, the original trilogy and (especially) the series’ later sequels have relied on star Johnny Depp’s charismatic portrayal of Captain Jack Sparrow to drive their increasingly elaborate and convoluted storylines.

As a result, acclaimed actors ranging from Zoe Saldana to Tom Hollander ended up underutilized in small roles that deserved more screen time and show focus. the Pirates of the Caribbean the movies introduced a slew of endearing characters, only to drop them soon after their first scenes to spend more time focusing on Jack’s antics. Among those memorable supporting stars was Tia Dalma/Calypso, a minor villain from the original trilogy.


Related: The Pirates Of The Caribbean 2 Scene Originally Written For Zorro

Portrayed by Naomie Harris, Pirates of the CaribbeanTia Dalma/Calypso might have been the franchise’s biggest threat and best villain, but she was spoiled by the show. The future Miss Moneypenny actress portrayed Tia Dalma as an enigmatic figure when she first appeared in late 2006. Pirates of the Caribbean continued Dead Man’s Chest. However, even that brief cameo hinted at his awesome powers with the character reviving the dead Captain Barbossa in the sequel’s explosive conclusion. Soon, the extent of Tia Dalma’s abilities were made clear when she transformed into the sea goddess Calypso in the closing scenes of the next film, 2007. At the end of the world. However, despite the epic reach of his powers, the character was never heard from again in the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise installments that followed.

Tia Dalma / Calypso explained

Naomie Harris as Tia Dalma in Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End

Powerful priestess, Tia Dalma first appeared as a kind of witch when she was visited by the heroes of the series at the end of Dead Man’s Chest. When she resurrects Captain Barbossa, she sets in motion a plan to reunite the nine Pirate Lords. The upcoming film reveals his reasoning for this. Tia Dalma is actually the immortal sea goddess Calypso, tricked into servitude by the Court of First Brethren after Davy Jones betrayed her despite their romantic history. Bringing the Pirate Lords together allowed them to free Calypso to defeat Jones, allowing the goddess to exact revenge on the lover who stabbed her in the back. She achieves this in the form of a formidable maelstrom that Calypso unleashes at the end of the original trilogy, killing many great Pirates of the Caribbean villains, including Cutler Beckett and Davy Jones. This scene showcases the impressive breadth of her abilities, but it’s also the only time the Pirates of the Caribbean the series takes advantage of it.

Why Tia Dalma/Calypso Was The Franchise’s Best Villain

The cabin of Tia Dalma in Pirates of the Caribbean Dead Man's Chest

Like Davy Jones’ pet Kraken (but even more dangerous), Calypso was a bigger threat than any other villain due to her sheer size. She was a literal god where the rest of the bad guys in the Pirates of the Caribbean the series were ghosts, zombies, or sea creatures, which made her much more threatening due to her size and abilities. This becomes evident when she is freed from her human form, transforming first into a giantess, then into a plague of crabs, and finally into a maelstrom that sinks most of the cast’s ships within minutes. Although the Pirates of the Caribbean the films never thought to portray her again (and limited her future appearances to an off-the-cuff reference in the fourth film), this finale leaves viewers in no doubt that Calypso is the most dangerous being in the franchise universe.

How the Pirates of the Caribbean Series Wasted It


Tia Dalma/Calypso’s love story with Davy Jones never really added up in terms of plot mechanics, but that wasn’t the biggest problem with the subplot. the Pirates of the Caribbean the movies wasted Tia Dalma’s potential by sticking her in a stereotypical love story that not only didn’t fully add up, but also limited her potential since the side story meant that almost all of her screen time had passed into a harmless human form. It was fascinating (and surprisingly sad) to watch Calypso reunite with the traitorous lover who had trapped her in a human body all those years ago. However, this scene occurred in the overloaded action of At the end of the world, robbing the moment of its potential emotional impact. Meanwhile, the fact that the third Pirates of the Caribbean The film’s finale was to conclude Elizabeth and Will’s love story, Jack’s escape from the law, the fate of the East India Trading Company, Bootstrap Bill’s debt to Davy Jones, and Jones’ death left little room for Calypso to take center stage.

Related: Pirates of the Caribbean’s Pirate Betrayal Was Deeper Than You Thought

Can Tia Dalma return in Pirates of the Caribbean 6?

Pirates of the Caribbean 6 Can't Kill Jack Sparrow Barbossa Davy Jones

Unlike many of the characters introduced earlier in the series, Tia Dalma might return in Pirates of the Caribbean 6. As a goddess, she is impossible to kill, and as a long-running supporting character in the series, she knows Jack, Captain Barbossa, and Davy Jones. Given that these three characters are the stars most likely to return or remain the focus of the Pirates of the Caribbean series, and they’re all related to her, Tia Dalma’s chance of a comeback even outweighs that of Barbossa’s daughter, Kaya Scodelario’s Carina. That said, the franchise may never get the chance to revive Tia Dalma because it’s unclear if the Pirates of the Caribbean series will be able to produce another sequel at all.

Why Calypso Might Never Return in Pirates of the Caribbean

Despite fans pressuring the franchise creators to bring Jack back, Pirates of the Caribbean 6 looks set to move forward with a new lead character. Depp’s ongoing personal issues led the franchise to drop him a few years ago, and it remains to be seen if starring Margot Robbie Pirates of the Caribbean the proposed 2020 reboot will bring back all of the supporting characters from the original films. To avoid reminding fans of Depp’s Jack Sparrow, Pirates of the Caribbean 6 might choose to drop her co-stars altogether. Thus, there is a high chance that the Pirates of the Caribbean the franchise will repeat their mistake and waste this nasty killer again.

More: Pirates of the Caribbean Role Brian Cox Denied

Ryan Reynolds Deadpool 2 Once Upon a Deadpool

Deadpool 3 isn’t filming in 2022 (Will the MCU movie film in 2023?)

About the Author

About Victoria Rothstein

Check Also

Author Emily Henry discusses ‘book lovers’ and pandemic writing

If Hallmark ever wanted to make a modern, romantic tale of The devil wears Prada, …